Enjoying Irrationality

I chanced upon this lecture given by Rory Sutherland at The Welcome conference and really enjoyed it thoroughly. I think it gives a lot of inspiration on what it means to go beyond the frontier when we’ve reached the limits of where rational optimisation has brought us – be it business or policymaking.

I also think he was right to first highlight that such thinking works better within certain domains (eg. marketing, hospitality, maybe F&B services). It could work well for certain aspects of policymaking, too. And I think it holds some lessons for the Singapore public service to certain extent.

It’s about 45 minutes long but I’m sure you’d find it a delight too.

Balanced transition II

At Blunomy, I lead our renewable fuel practice. Sometimes it feels like a forgotten sibling of renewable electricity. Electrification is often the first port of call for decarbonisation, never mind that it is just passing the buck to centralised generation. And then there’s the renewable energy procurement through the certification instrument where there is usually no need for matching the time of generation with the time of use – mostly just reconciliation of the gross amount of energy injected into the grid and what was withdrawn for the user on the same month, sometimes even just for the year.

Yet when it comes to renewable fuels, we hold it up to a higher standard. It needs to be mass balanced and the physical commodity will need enter the tank of the owner claiming the use of the renewable fuel. Book-and-claim makes sense to reduce logistical cost and overall compliance cost but it is deemed not as legit or at least not giving enough confidence.

And then there are all sorts of requirements for the production of green hydrogen, including trying to match the time of hydrogen production with that of the green electricity injection into the grid. You get my drift.

Renewable fuel needs to get started sooner rather than later to move our world away from the trajectory that is going beyond 2-degree Celsius warming scenario. And more often than not, in order to grow something mainstream and to achieve the cost reductions that are necessary for broad adoption, we need to get started at small scale. This means expensive fuel, and we sometimes think with this scarcity, we ought to reserve it for use-cases for which there are no alternative decarbonisation. That is probably not always true because at this stage when the fossil alternatives are still broadly available, it is all about willingness-to-pay and channeling the resources to pay for it.

Elon Musk have been incredibly successful at using the capital markets for this end – to be able to fund the scaling up needed to get the cost down. He also successfully identify plausible markets and use-case to pitch into where the capital he raises won’t seem like it is hanging high and dry – that there are people with money willing to pay for the high-end EVs that Tesla churns, or the satellite-launching services that SpaceX could bring about.

The capital market quite frankly hasn’t been all that kind to the energy or climate transition. I think part of the reason is that there’s often this altruistic motive behind the bulk of the pioneering capital there – not the greed-driven ones. And since the transition has such a reputation of not being the favourite of those sharks, it would seem like there was hardly much money to be made there.

And then there is regulations not really wanting to take the fall for raising cost of living when it tries to push the economy towards lower carbon intensity. All of these serves to drive a very unbalanced transition that is skewed towards technologies and approaches to transition where someone else somehow pays for the transition. Take renewable electricity for example; majority of it is intermittent and so the costs is more on the grid infrastructure – which is typically socialised in many jurisdictions. It’s easier to sell green electricity cheap (solar LCOE!) and then load the costs on the grid investments and let the end-users foot the bill by force in order to remain on the networks.

There isn’t really sufficient system level thinking that is operating at the moment across the world when tackling this issue of the transition. There’s a lot of obsession with asking ‘what is the right answer’ to displace/replace fossil when the question should be more about considering what would be an energy system we want to build, and what are the attributes worth building towards.

Balanced transition

My work in the energy transition over the past decade or so have been about fossil fuel diversification but also about renewables diversification. As the system gets more and more electrified, the point of failures shifts from the end-nodes of the energy consumption system (eg. engines, electrical points, etc.) to the transmission and distribution systems, as well as the point of generation.

This is why energy mix features strongly as something that requires government to plan and determine. Singapore’s power generation fleet is ~95% natural gas and hence there is huge risk in being exposed to international gas supply. So we are technically using a mix of long-term contracts and short-term ones, as well as a mix of piped natural gas and liquefied natural gas.

But that is all fossil. What about renewable power? We have been relying on solar power off the rooftops, the mobile plants on empty plots, and the floating solar on reservoirs and that is great. And then we’re thinking of importing renewables from neighbouring countries, which involves long subsea cables at high voltages to transmit the power to Singapore. In order to use the asset well, it is best that the power transmitted is firm and not renewables so you don’t have to oversize the transmission capacity. So you put batteries for those wind and solar power; and then you also try to import hydroelectricity.

But what happens during the dry season (low water levels and hence low hydro), when there are forest fires and haze that block out the sun’s rays and reduce solar yield?

As we are deep within another season of transboundary haze pollution problem, we notice that the energy transition plans may require greater understanding of risks. If the entire region’s energy that we’re relying upon is mainly solar-based, a severe haze event could reduce power yield and result in supply inadequacy. This is regardless of how much battery power you have in the system because the firming is more to smooth out the volatility and system fluctuations across a day, not to deal with capacity factor or yield reductions.

And this brings me to the argument that we need to make the energy transition with a kind of diversification that we do when we had fossil sources in our energy mix as well. We need to be able to secure different, uncorrelated forms of supply and energy vectors in order to maintain supply resilience and stability, even if that may mean a blow to the price/cost impacts. Take it as an insurance premium of sorts. We are buffering ourselves from having to scramble for just what everyone needs when the crisis happens.

Often, this means importing green fuels. That could be biomethane produced from anaerobic digestion of waste water or other wet organic waste streams. It could also mean biodiesel, renewable diesel, or other biofuels produced from organic residues and waste fats and oils from regional markets. This would help us diversify our sources of energy not just geographically but also the pathways that we are relying on so that we are not at the mercy of an energy crisis whenever there is forest fires.

At the same time, developing demand for biomass residue and putting pressure on valorising biomass waste can change incentives for the plantations and forestry industry. If aggregating the waste, processing it can provide a slight return better than break-even, it might make sense for them to do so rather than burning the waste in the forests or fields. The balanced transition requires more systems thinking.

Developing the market II

I wrote about the challenges of putting a price discovery process ahead of a market development step. When I look into markets like China, US or even India, market development is very much the main process because they are likely able to produce many different types of commodities and hence anyone who needs something would or could scour the market in search of that commodity or product.

Now if it is difficult to obtain the product because of limited number of producers, you would then undertake the activity of actually developing the supply chains and producing it, assuming that you are able to line up all that is required to start producing it. We are now all operating in the same market, so it would make sense for large corporations because that reflects growth, and for governments as well because it creates jobs and boost economic activities.

Basically, if the market is underdeveloped, instead of buying off the market, you will have to somehow build it yourself. And that means building out the entire value chain. Because going out to ask for a quote will likely give you ridiculous figures from traders and potentially scalpers.

Smaller economies that are unlikely to be able to build supply chains and produce within their own economies would likely have to go elsewhere to seek out the product or commodity. This means finding out where there are already markets already available, getting a sense of the cost, factoring it into their considerations, or developing a full supply chain into their own economies by themselves.

Trading economies like Singapore and Hong Kong are really strong at the price discovery portion, focusing on short term cost reductions, seeking out the most cost-competitive sources. Perhaps the mature, yet geographically disadvantaged economies like Korea and Japan in particularly is really strong at the longer term approach of developing the full supply chain into their own economies and strengthening real economic linkages across borders.

What this means is that Hong Kong and Singapore may be disadvantaged by their approach towards markets when it comes to sustainability and the transition. Part of the reason is that being trading nations, most of the genuine manufacturing base is not actually in the country (demand pushes doesn’t work so well); and for the limited activities that are to be ‘decarbonized’, the ability to do so with domestic resources is limited. When the demand side such as Europe or America starts demanding for ‘decarbonised’ products through various policy instruments or corporate targets, especially when the green fuel, green electricity markets are not sufficiently mature in Asia Pacific, some of those supply chains and relationships will shift.

Japan is able to develop these value chains and build up the ability to connect resources back to their economy mainly because of the strength of their corporates which dominates their domestic economy and also string up a lot of their local supply chains including small-medium enterprises. The large corporations can then draw the resources and potentially even raw materials back into their domestic economy to feed inputs to the other domestic players who could produce for the rest of the world.

Perhaps one day I’d conduct more research into the economic strategies and growth paths of these various Asian economies and what it means for the emerging Asia economies in Southeast Asia.

Developing the market

In my day job, I provide strategy, commercial as well as policy advice particularly related to the energy transition. We aim to support players to make evidence-based decisions and to ground their decisions on proper assessment of risks and the dynamics underlying the operating environment.

One of the big mistakes I have been encountering when it comes to the energy transition is that market players (including government) have this mistaken idea that certain solutions are not viable or possible after trying to get a sense of pricing when a market has not been developed. In essence, price discovery can only take place after establishing a market. We can try to work out the cost of bringing certain products into the market, but that is different from trying to call a tender a have a price discovery process.

Take for example biomethane in Southeast Asia. There are pockets of it already produced, and you would be able to get price quotes for delivery of the products to where you need. Maybe you could also sign a long term contract on a small volume but pricing is going to be high because the players would put in more margins in order to deal with their risks. The lack of liquidity and a fleshed out market leads to distortions in price quotes. Moreover, biomethane being a gas means that transport cost can be a huge portion of the delivered cost if you are situated far from the original source.

Logically, you could put the biomethane into the national gas networks and then distribute it using mass balance methodologies. However, there are issues and questions around gas grid access – the immaturity of regulations around open gas grid access in Southeast Asia makes things a bit more complex and that gets amplified when you consider cross-border trades, and even liquefaction.

Don’t get me wrong, complex markets do exists. The global LNG market is a marvel, and our agrifood supply chains are truly an amazing showing of what the free market does. But these markets took time to develop and have had to go through a process of evolution where the supply is driven by initial demand and the willingness to build infrastructure to support all that.

The same principle applies to cross-border renewable electricity; there is typically a gradual process of working out the infrastructure costs, understanding the approaches towards delivery of the electricity, developing feasibility studies and so on. Having diversified sources is all well-and-good but that works when you are accessing markets that have developed supply available to make these happen.

No matter how sophisticated your price discovery process is; it will not deliver in an environment where the market is under-developed.

Driving the market

The challenge with over-financialisation is that price signals get confused in the market. We are trying to make prices mean too many different things. And there gradually is some kind of misallocation. This is probably something not studied deeply enough in economics because it’s always been glossed over in the assumptions about free markets.

We often think only about the demand and supply sides of free markets, but never quite about the income side. The assumption is that incomes then unlock the demand back in the free market. Yet the income side of the equation also changes the underlying demand. A society that has higher concentration of wealth will have a different demand profile than one that has lower concentration of wealth.

Not to mention that different regulations and rules will divert income and wealth in different ways. Countries with stricter labour regulations can have higher unemployment, but wages can also tend to be higher, and that gives rise to a broader middle class while also resulting in labour-based services commanding higher prices, and changing the value of goods vis-a-vis services.

The philosophy to leave things to the market isn’t neutral per se. We cannot make a conscious decision to say this or that should be left to the market and then disclaim the negative consequences of it. Once we institute a market, or any other policies, we ought to recognise the presence of winners and losers, and then the overall system needs to deal with the shortfall of the system.

In the HDB for example, the government seeks to ‘subsidise’ housing for the BTO flats but allow secondary ‘resale’ transactions to be ‘priced’ by the market. Yet this pricing is subject to forces such as private housing prices, which is in turn related to land sales and also buying power from foreign capital. This means that as much as we try to create the two-track market to ensure locals have access to affordable housing, it is subject to forces on the other side. Ultimately, the tension is political – with so much wealth of the people locked in real estate, can the government or the political parties allow for massive collapse in real estate value to ‘reset’ costs for a younger generation?

And if not, how can we ensure that intergenerational wealth transfers do not massively handicap those who do not receive them? Do we then intervene in the market? I would think that the market continues and should be part of the whole suite of allocation mechanisms available for policy-makers but treating it like the default approach for allocation of everything would be wrong.

Prompt too far

While engineering our prompts well can maximise the possibility of a good result from GenAI tools that we are using, it is also important to understand the technology, the features that AI are really good at, and the things that they are really poor at so that you’re leveraging the right strengths and not wasting your tokens or prompting attempts on things that are fundamentally not going to come out of the AI tool.

One thing to appreciate, especially for GenAI, is that LLMs are designed to provide you with high probability responses that will be considered ‘right’ or ‘appropriate’ by human raters. So even though they are trained on a large amount of data and information, it is difficult to necessarily weight the information appropriately to your needs when giving you a response. As a result, they would tend to give you motherhood statements that have a high probability of being on-point even if they are tangentially related to what you are really looking for. You may be able to guide it in your prompt to go a bit more specific towards what you want, but essentially, you’ll have to do the work of narrowing down things. This is because the LLM is designed not to clarify your questions and sharpen their output for you – that’s something that you are supposed to do. Yet at the same time, they would already be consuming your tokens even during that process while you’re ‘finetuning’ them towards your output.

The other challenge for LLM is the problem of hallucination and even creating false data or connections. Quite often even when they are citing or linking to certain sources, the LLMs are making guesses on the content and association with what you’re searching for and also what they are ‘talking about’ themselves. So an assertion may be associated with a link they furnish you, rather than being based on that link. This is radically different from academic citations when your ‘sources’ are really saying or validating what you are saying. Most GenAI tools simply provide materials that may be associated rather than actually make certain points. Worse still, they could make up links that are broken and claim them as source.

Of course, there’s a whole issue around existing softwares being replaced by AI or vibe-coding. Often, this involves almost reinventing the wheel. Yes, maybe the prototyping cost has come down: what AI has done is that it has taken down some of the initial barriers in getting some kind of digital product out. But all that without providing a proper long-term infrastructure planning or system thinking because it is not exactly optimising towards a longer-term vision. This means a lot more resources dealing with bugs and bolting on new features or other aspects of the software in a way that is not optimised at the system level. Moreover, the AI companies are themselves competing with their own customers and users in developing the more bespoke tools for those willing-to-pay clients. So what makes you think you are going to vibe-code your way to a proper product people will pay you for?

Making judgments

One of the things that the modern democracies are struggling now is with making clear judgment or assessments about things including truth. Having been used to mostly civil public discourse for decades, there are groups which are sick of endless debates and trying to take shortcuts. And often, the shortcuts means both the left and right of society are coroborating to destroy the foundations of democratic debates and wrestling but instead resorting to de facto power.

If that is seen as a solution to winning the superpower race for the US, it is seriously misguided. De facto power isn’t so much what reigns in China. Rather, it is ultimately a government’s care for countrymen and ability to uplift the bottom strata of society that wins legitimacy and organising authority. Think of governance and leadership in any country as an organising authority – this group helps coordinate things that do not naturally emerge in the market, and make decisions on trade-offs.

Democracy tries to push the debate on trade-offs to a wider, more diverse group and that forms politics. But what are the issues to push out and what are those to be decided by the bureacrats is something to be determined by culture and society. Ideally, devolution of power to the local helps ensure the higher levels of government focus on the most critical issues.

But that’s the rationalistic approach. Reality is more complex because politics always finds its way to play the rules rather than by the rules. So local authority uses devolved power to block larger developments, and higher levels of government sometimes have to do horse trading of issues. Regardless of the ills of the system, we need to determine if this is the way to make the best judgment for the overall society. Sure, things may benefit one segment of the population but not others; but at the very least, people can agree on a course of action suited for the society over the longer time horizon.

I think part of the lack of judgment have to do with the way philosophy is taught and viewed in our society these days. Different ideas are taught without recognising what frameworks are suitable for what kind of context and decisions. And at the same time, this coincides with the relativisation of moral values. The less we consider and cultivate broader civic virtues in society, the more it reflects in our politics less of it.

Applying judgments in the society requires that some basic principles and values be accepted broadly as the foundation of the society. If everything is subjective and relative, then politics becomes simply a beauty contest with extremely irratic outcomes.

It’s now or never

It’s Good Friday and while in the car with my wife, the song by Elvis Presley, ‘It’s now or never’ came up and I asked her, isn’t this the tune of a hymn?

She said no, it’s an old song.

I said, it’s definitely a hymn. And I searched, realised it was ‘Down from His glory’ that shared the same melody as the Elvis Presley song, which was based on a very old Neapolitan (some kind of dialect of Italy though recognise almost as a distinct language) song, ‘O Sole Mio’ (written in 1898). The title translates to ‘My Sunshine’ and the original song was a bit of a love song that used ‘sun’ or ‘sunshine’ point to his subject of adoration.

Meanwhile, Down from His glory was written by William Booth-Clibborn in 1921. He is not to be confused with his own maternal grandfather, William Booth, founder of the Salvation Army. What I thought was interesting was how William Booth-Clibborn basically paid tribute to the source of the melody for which he composed his hymn with the lines in the chorus:

O how I love Him! How I adore Him!
My breath, my sunshine, my all in all.

What a wonderful way a love song had been directed towards the praise and adoration of the Lord! In contrast, ‘It’s now or never’, despite Elvis’ musical talents and brilliance in delivering this somewhat seductive song, becomes so superficial and pale in comparison to the depth of William Booth-Clibborn’s hymn.

Maundy Thursday 2026

A year ago, I reflected on Maundy Thursday and also shared about what this word ‘maundy’ was referring to. Maundy refers to the command – and this command was to “love one another as I have loved you” (John 13:34). The focus of this term was not so much on the last supper, nor the betrayal of Jesus, but on the washing of the disciples’ feet.

There is always a lot to unpack within the gospel for the record, leading up to the crucifixion of Jesus Christ in these two days. But we continue to focus on this feet-washing matter. What does it mean, why does it matter and what of this experience did the disciples take away?

On one hand, Jesus washing of the disciples’ feet is a matter of service. He was demonstrating to the disciples the level of humility that they are all called to. John the Baptist said that he was not worthy to loose/untie the sandal strap of Jesus (John 1:27) and yet here was Jesus, washing the feet of His disciples. And in John 13:14-17, Jesus clearly expects that the example he set will make a strong impression in the disciples to follow his example of love and service. The mandate to love one another then follows from there.

On the other hand, we got to peer even more deeply into the spiritual meaning of feet-washing from the perspective of those whose feet are being washed. This is perhaps thanks to Peter, who tried to ask Jesus to wash his head and hands after Jesus said that Peter had no part with Him if He didn’t wash Peter’s feet. Peter probably tries to say that all of him is with Jesus and therefore asks to be washed fully. But Jesus explains further that ‘He who is bathed needs only to wash his feet, but is completely clean’ (John 13:10). So the feet washing is not just symbolic of the loving and serving of the one who washes. There was a separate point being brought up.

And this is the point that daily cleansing of the filth from the world (sanctification) is needed, even when we have been cleansed through salvation. There will always be influences from the world that draws us to sin and we would have our personal struggles that we are dealing with – the daily cleansing, with the Lord’s word, with prayer, mutual encouragement and service (which can come through a gentle rebuke, or holding one another accountable) will allow us to sanctify one another to the Lord.

All of these mattered to Jesus at the point before His betrayal and crucifixion (noting the way John wrote verses 2-3). This was almost the last time the disciples gathered together, and Jesus was certainly teaching them the final lessons He could share and leave with them directly before His death. There’s one common misunderstanding that I’d like to tidy up before finishing this post. The question is whether Judas’ feet were washed. Given that Jesus alluded to the fact that Judas was ‘unclean’ in John 13:10-11. The difficulty of John 13’s record is that verses 1-17 about feet washing comes first but then verses 18-30 where Jesus identifies his betrayer comes later. So there’s this impression that Jesus washed the feet of all his disciples and then subsequently Judas left.

But if you read verse 2 carefully, you realise that the elements of the flowing prose from verses 1-30 isn’t chronologically ordered. The foot washing took place immediately after supper. Whereas verses 18-38 was almost like a flashback to the times the supper when Jesus and his disciples were still eating, and then Judas went out from them and Jesus continued teaching, giving the command to love, and then predicting Peter’s denial.

I have not looked into why John wrote the way he did but I had thought that John must have been so deeply impacted by having his feet washed by Jesus and he wanted to write about that and show how Jesus lived out this ‘mandate’ while he was alive, and also how this related to the cleansing the disciples needed vis-a-vis the one they already had (salvation received in their hearts). By sharing this experience first and then unpacking the rest in the next couple of chapters, John was prefacing Jesus’ teachings with first the revelation of who His person was like from His action.

To be a Christian, the person of Jesus needs to hit us, the manner He taught with His life and not just His words. It is the consciousness of His life that enables us to cling on to His words.